As the Q1 earnings season comes to a close, it’s time to take stock of this quarter’s best and worst performers in the property & casualty insurance industry, including Employers Holdings (NYSE: EIG) and its peers.

Property & Casualty (P&C) insurers protect individuals and businesses against financial loss from damage to property or from legal liability. This is a cyclical industry, and the sector benefits when there is 'hard market', characterized by strong premium rate increases that outpace loss and cost inflation, resulting in robust underwriting margins. The opposite is true in a 'soft market'. Interest rates also matter, as they determine the yields earned on fixed-income portfolios. On the other hand, P&C insurers face a major secular headwind from the increasing frequency and severity of catastrophe losses due to climate change. Furthermore, the liability side of the business is pressured by 'social inflation'—the trend of rising litigation costs and larger jury awards.

The 32 property & casualty insurance stocks we track reported a mixed Q1. As a group, revenues beat analysts’ consensus estimates by 1.9%.

In light of this news, share prices of the companies have held steady as they are up 3.2% on average since the latest earnings results.

Employers Holdings (NYSE: EIG)

With roots in Nevada and a strong concentration in California where 45% of its premiums are generated, Employers Holdings (NYSE: EIG) is a specialty provider of workers' compensation insurance focused on small and select businesses engaged in low-to-medium hazard industries across the United States.

Employers Holdings reported revenues of $207.6 million, up 2.5% year on year. This print fell short of analysts’ expectations by 1.9%. Overall, it was a softer quarter for the company with a significant miss of analysts’ net premiums earned and book value per share estimates.

Chief Executive Officer Katherine Antonello commented: “This was a quarter defined by discipline. We made a deliberate choice to prioritize underwriting quality over volume, and the results reflect that commitment: our underwriting expense ratio improved, our actuarial estimates came in on target, and we returned $83.0 million to shareholders while growing book value per share including the Deferred Gain by 8.9%."

Interestingly, the stock is up 11.4% since reporting and currently trades at $47.66.

Read our full report on Employers Holdings here, it’s free.

Best Q1: Stewart Information Services (NYSE: STC)

Founded in 1893 during America's westward expansion when property records were often disputed, Stewart Information Services (NYSE: STC) provides title insurance and real estate services, helping homebuyers, sellers, and lenders verify property ownership and protect against title defects.

Stewart Information Services reported revenues of $781.3 million, up 27.7% year on year, outperforming analysts’ expectations by 4.6%. The business had an incredible quarter with a beat of analysts’ EPS estimates.

Although it had a fine quarter compared to its peers, the market seems unhappy with the results as the stock is down 1.3% since reporting. It currently trades at $67.44.

Is now the time to buy Stewart Information Services? Access our full analysis of the earnings results here, it’s free.

Weakest Q1: Fidelity National Financial (NYSE: FNF)

Issuing more title insurance policies than any other company in the United States, Fidelity National Financial (NYSE: FNF) provides title insurance and escrow services for real estate transactions while also offering annuities and life insurance through its F&G subsidiary.

Fidelity National Financial reported revenues of $3.23 billion, up 18.2% year on year, falling short of analysts’ expectations by 10.7%. It was a disappointing quarter as it posted a significant miss of analysts’ EPS estimates.

Fidelity National Financial delivered the weakest performance against analyst estimates in the group. As expected, the stock is down 8.8% since the results and currently trades at $46.77.

Read our full analysis of Fidelity National Financial’s results here.

HCI Group (NYSE: HCI)

Starting as a Florida "take-out" insurer that assumed policies from the state-backed Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, HCI Group (NYSE: HCI) provides property and casualty insurance, primarily homeowners coverage, while leveraging proprietary technology to improve underwriting and claims processing.

HCI Group reported revenues of $242.9 million, up 12.2% year on year. This result missed analysts’ expectations by 1.1%. More broadly, it was actually a strong quarter as it recorded a solid beat of analysts’ book value per share estimates and an impressive beat of analysts’ net premiums earned estimates.

The stock is up 12% since reporting and currently trades at $172.31.

Read our full, actionable report on HCI Group here, it’s free.

Trupanion (NASDAQ: TRUP)

Born from a vision to help pet owners avoid economic euthanasia when faced with expensive veterinary bills, Trupanion (NASDAQ: TRUP) provides medical insurance for cats and dogs through data-driven, vertically-integrated products priced specifically for each pet's unique characteristics.

Trupanion reported revenues of $384 million, up 12.3% year on year. This number surpassed analysts’ expectations by 1.1%. Overall, it was an exceptional quarter as it also put up a beat of analysts’ EPS estimates and an impressive beat of analysts’ book value per share estimates.

The stock is down 1.8% since reporting and currently trades at $23.57.

Read our full, actionable report on Trupanion here, it’s free.

Market Update

Late in 2025 into early 2026, there was hand-wringing around artificial intelligence. For software companies, the fear was that AI would erode pricing power and compress margins as new tools made it easier to replicate what once required expensive enterprise platforms. Crypto investors had their own version of the same anxiety: if AI agents could trade, allocate capital, and manage wallets autonomously, what exactly was the long-term value of today’s crypto infrastructure?

These concerns triggered a noticeable rotation away from these sectors and into safer havens. But markets rarely dwell on one narrative for long. Spring 2026 came, and the focus shifted abruptly from technological disruption to geopolitical risk. The US’ conflict with Iran became the dominant driver of market psychology, and when geopolitics takes center stage, the script changes quickly. Investors stop debating growth rates and start worrying about oil supply, inflation, and global stability.

Want to invest in winners with rock-solid fundamentals? Check out our Top 5 Quality Compounder Stocks and add them to your watchlist. These companies are poised for growth regardless of the political or macroeconomic climate.